Manchester City, Arsenal, premier League, Nottingham Forest, Manchester United

Ranking the Most Complaining Premier League Fanbases of 2024/25

July 3, 2025 Rasmus Kristensen

It’s no secret that football fans love to voice their opinions — and sometimes their frustrations — especially in the modern age of social media. From heated rants on X to passionate debates on Instagram, supporters rarely hold back when their beloved clubs fail to meet expectations. Using data that tracked the percentage of negative comments from each fanbase during the 2024/25 Premier League season, we can see exactly which sets of supporters were the most vocal — or the most disgruntled.

What’s striking is that some of the clubs with the highest negativity actually enjoyed strong seasons, proving that in football, ambition and hope often breed as much anxiety as satisfaction. Here’s a closer look, starting with the happiest supporters at Bournemouth and ending with the most restless at Aston Villa.

Bournemouth

Bournemouth fans were the happiest in the Premier League last season, with only 13.32% of their comments being negative. Under Andoni Iraola, the Cherries made an unexpected push for European places before slipping late on, but supporters still kept a remarkably positive outlook. It shows how simply staying competitive in the top flight continues to satisfy most Bournemouth faithful.

Fulham

Fulham supporters posted a negativity level of 14.75%, reflecting a calm and measured fanbase despite their team floating around mid-table. The Cottagers didn’t threaten Europe or face serious relegation danger, and that stability seems to have kept frustration to a minimum. For a club that’s yo-yoed in recent years, avoiding drama is a quiet win.

Southampton

Despite suffering relegation, Southampton fans surprisingly only registered 15.23% negativity. Saints supporters have grown somewhat accustomed to life bouncing between the Premier League and the Championship, and many appear philosophical about the club’s long-term challenges. Instead of constant outrage, they’re choosing to back their side for a hopeful return.

Ipswich Town

Ipswich Town marked their return to the Premier League with spirited performances, and their fans had a negativity rate of just 16.12%. For a newly promoted side battling to stay up, that’s impressive patience. Most Ipswich supporters were simply thrilled to be back in the top flight after such a long absence, showing gratitude rather than discontent.

Brighton

Brighton fans recorded 16.32% negative comments during a season that failed to hit their previous European heights. Even so, the Seagulls faithful mostly stayed supportive, recognizing the club’s incredible progress in recent years. Occasional frustration over inconsistent results didn’t boil over into outright bitterness.

Brentford

Brentford’s supporters showed 16.47% negativity, not bad considering they flirted with relegation. Fans of the Bees seem to appreciate the bigger picture: staying competitive in the Premier League on a modest budget is still a significant achievement. That long-term perspective helped keep widespread complaints in check.

Nottingham Forest

Nottingham Forest fans registered a 16.54% negativity percentage in a chaotic season that somehow ended with a return to European football. Defensive issues and off-pitch distractions might have sparked more criticism elsewhere, but Forest’s remarkable survival stories and flashes of brilliance kept most supporters rallying behind the team.

Manchester United

Given the turmoil at Old Trafford, it’s surprising that Manchester United fans only posted 16.90% negativity. A string of underwhelming results and persistent off-field questions could have driven much harsher reactions. Perhaps years of frustration have led some supporters to adopt a weary, more resigned outlook.

Liverpool

Liverpool fans posted 17.11% negativity, relatively moderate considering the intense scrutiny around the club. They captured the Premier League title but stumbled in domestic cups and Europe, which stirred pockets of frustration. For a club with global ambitions, even small missteps invite criticism — though overall the mood remained upbeat.

Crystal Palace

Crystal Palace supporters logged 17.85% negative comments, even after the club won its first-ever major trophy by lifting the FA Cup. Securing silverware brought immense joy, but concerns about squad depth and consistency still simmered online. Success didn’t erase all worries, and fans made sure their voices were heard.

West Ham United

West Ham fans reached an 18.03% negativity mark, driven by a turbulent season that saw multiple managerial changes. Replacing David Moyes didn’t go as planned, and while hopes remain high under Graham Potter, many supporters spent the year voicing frustration at a club that seems stuck between ambition and instability.

Newcastle United

Newcastle supporters registered 18.19% negative comments despite a season that delivered both a trophy and a Champions League return. Some of that criticism likely ties back to a quiet transfer window, which left ambitious fans anxious about the club’s next step. Even historic highs couldn’t fully dampen expectations.

Chelsea

Chelsea recorded 18.36% negativity, reflecting fans who still carry deep skepticism from recent missteps under Todd Boehly. A top-four finish and a Conference League trophy under Enzo Maresca steadied things, but goalkeeper mistakes and patchy form gave fans plenty of reason to vent online.

Leicester City

Leicester City’s relegation campaign saw supporters hit 18.55% negativity, which is fairly restrained given how far they’ve fallen since their miracle title. Saying goodbye to club legend Jamie Vardy only added to the emotional weight. It’s a fanbase still processing a painful step back.

Arsenal

Arsenal fans posted 19.28% negativity, with most frustration revolving around controversial refereeing calls and the lack of a prolific striker. Falling just short in another intense title race under Mikel Arteta left supporters both proud and aggravated — a familiar emotional cocktail in North London.

Wolverhampton Wanderers

Wolves fans reached 19.38% negativity after a bumpy season that required a managerial change to stay comfortably safe. Losing standout Matheus Cunha to Manchester United already has supporters worried about the future, and many spent the season questioning whether the club is really building toward something better.

Everton

Everton’s supporters showed 19.41% negativity, understandable after years battling relegation and enduring points deductions. A 13th-place finish under new leadership helped calm nerves slightly, but scars remain. The return of David Moyes brought a flicker of hope, though fans still held onto plenty of skepticism.

Manchester City

Manchester City fans posted 19.60% negativity, proving just how high the bar is at the Etihad. Finishing third in the league, losing the FA Cup final, and exiting the Champions League knockout stage all counted as major letdowns for a fanbase used to sweeping it all. Even minor setbacks now fuel major discontent.

Tottenham Hotspur

Tottenham supporters landed at 19.87% negativity, despite finally winning a trophy and securing a Champions League spot. The sudden sacking of Ange Postecoglou only stoked the unrest. Spurs fans are notorious for being hard to satisfy, and even genuine progress couldn’t change that dynamic much.

Aston Villa

Aston Villa topped the list with 20.41% negativity, the highest in the Premier League. Fans voiced frustration throughout a season that still saw the club reach the Champions League quarterfinals and narrowly miss out on the top four. Big-name arrivals like Marcus Rashford and Marco Asensio raised expectations, which meant supporters were quick to spotlight any shortfall.