Top 10 Goalscorers Without Penalties in the 21st Century
Scoring goals is one thing—but doing so without relying on penalties is a testament to a player's true finishing ability. In this article, we rank the top 10 players with the most non-penalty goals since the year 2000, highlighting the sheer consistency and skill of some of football's most iconic strikers. Let’s count down from number 10 to number 1.
10. Samuel Eto’o – 378 Goals
One of Africa’s greatest ever forwards, Samuel Eto’o terrorized defences at Barcelona, Inter Milan, and beyond. His 378 non-penalty goals came across 880 matches, showcasing his consistent output throughout a storied career.
9. Sergio Aguero – 378 Goals
Aguero was Manchester City’s talisman for a decade, blending agility with ruthless finishing. With 378 goals in 786 games excluding penalties, he was one of the Premier League’s deadliest strikers.
8. Edinson Cavani – 403 Goals
The Uruguayan hitman thrived in Italy, France, and England, always hunting space in the box. Cavani’s 403 non-penalty goals underline his intelligence and movement during a career that spanned over 800 matches.
Read also: The 18 Highest-Paid Arsenal Players – Ranked from Lowest to Highest
7. Edin Dzeko – 426 Goals
Often overlooked in lists of elite strikers, Edin Dzeko quietly racked up 426 goals without a single penalty. With a physical presence and strong aerial ability, he proved valuable at clubs like Wolfsburg, City, and Roma.
6. Karim Benzema – 456 Goals
Overshadowed for years by Cristiano Ronaldo at Real Madrid, Benzema built his own legacy through efficiency and elegance. His 456 non-penalty goals illustrate just how prolific he’s been, even when not taking spot-kicks.
5. Zlatan Ibrahimovic – 488 Goals
Known as much for his personality as his goals, Ibrahimovic delivered everywhere he went—from Milan to Paris to LA. Scoring 488 goals without penalties, he embodied the art of spectacular, creative finishing.
4. Luis Suarez – 537 Goals
Suarez’s fiery passion and relentless drive made him a nightmare for defenders across Europe and South America. His 537 goals without penalties reveal just how lethal he was in open play, especially during his peak years at Liverpool and Barcelona.
Read also: The 32 Best Footballers of the 1990s – Ranked
3. Robert Lewandowski – 622 Goals
Lewandowski’s game is built on positioning, timing, and elite composure in front of goal. With 622 non-penalty strikes in fewer than 1,000 matches, his consistency across Bundesliga and La Liga is nearly unmatched.
2. Cristiano Ronaldo – 763 Goals
Though known for his overall goal tally, Ronaldo’s 763 non-penalty goals stand as proof of his natural finishing instincts. His ability to find the net from all areas of the pitch has remained constant across nearly 1,300 games.
1. Lionel Messi – 764 Goals
Topping the list is the Argentine maestro, Lionel Messi, with 764 non-penalty goals. His playmaking vision combined with clinical finishing makes him not only football’s most creative force but also its deadliest scorer from open play.
Read also: AI Unveils the Ultimate 23-Man All-European Squad in Football History
Read also: The 18 Most Expensive Sales from Each Bundesliga Club - Ranked from Lowest to Highest
