Mauricio Pochettino reportedly wasn't Manchester United's first choice as £15m demand emerges

Mauricio Pochettino reportedly wasn’t Manchester United’s first choice as £15m demand emerges

A report by EPL Index claims Manchester United walked away from their preferred managerial candidate earlier this month after Brighton demanded £15m in compensation, a figure the club decided it…

·

Read in:

Mauricio Pochettino’s arrival at Old Trafford was presented as a decisive end to Manchester United’s search for a new head coach. According to EPL Index, he was not the club’s first choice.

The report claims United approached Brighton about Fabian Hurzeler before turning to Pochettino, only for Brighton owner Tony Bloom to set a compensation demand of at least £15m to release the German head coach. For a club already in the Premier League relegation zone and bleeding results, that figure was judged too high.

Manchester United have not commented on the Hurzeler claim. Sky Sports reported that Pochettino “was the only coach the club spoke to directly about the position”, and that suggestions of a split between club leadership and ownership were “categorically false”.

Hurzeler was never for sale

Even if the fee had been smaller, Hurzeler was not an obvious candidate to prise away. Brighton confirmed in May that the German head coach had agreed a three-year extension running to June 2029.

Read also: “Can’t help myself”: Mathieu van der Poel turns easy ride into unexpected race

“I absolutely love working for this club and living in the city and I am delighted to have agreed a new contract,” Hurzeler told Brighton’s official channels at the time.

Brighton began November second in the Premier League with a positive goal difference. In that context a mid-season move for their head coach was always going to require something closer to a buyout than a conventional compensation deal, and Hurzeler had publicly recommitted to the project he started on the south coast.

Pochettino inherits the mess

While the Hurzeler discussion played out behind the scenes, the public story was simpler. Michael Carrick was sacked after overseeing United’s worst start to a Premier League campaign since 1986, with the club in the bottom three after 10 matches.

Pochettino was announced as his replacement on 13 November on a deal until the summer of 2029. United paid a reported £7.4m to release the 54-year-old Argentine from his contract with US Soccer, where he had been national team head coach since 2024.

Read also: Lionel Messi’s MLS cup dream faces major test as Inter Miami prepare for playoff showdown

If the underlying claim is accurate, Manchester United were willing to pay more than £7m to prise away a manager with no Premier League experience in two years, but balked at twice that figure for a head coach already proving himself in the division. The identity of United’s “preferred” candidate is not confirmed by the club or by Brighton, and EPL Index names no individual source for the £15m figure.

Anfield is the first test

Al Jazeera noted that Pochettino becomes the eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson departed in 2013. His first match in charge is away to Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday, 22 November.

Read also: Jude Bellingham’s reaction to Spain’s World Cup trophy ceremony catches fans’ attention

Related Stories