Premier League admits major VAR error in Everton victory as Frank Lampard vindicated

Premier League admits major VAR error in Everton victory as Frank Lampard vindicated

The Key Match Incidents Panel unanimously decided that referee Stuart Attwell and VAR got the call wrong in Everton’s 3-1 win over Coventry on 6 November, concluding a penalty and…

·

Read in:

James Tarkowski had hold of Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair in the first half at the Hill Dickinson Stadium. Stuart Attwell, officiating a few yards away, saw no foul. VAR did not intervene. On Wednesday, the Premier League’s own review panel decided every one of those calls was wrong.

All five members of the Key Match Incidents Panel agreed that Tarkowski should have been penalised and shown a yellow card, according to the published panel verdict. “Tarkowski had hold of Yirenkyi’s hair as the Coventry attacker attempted to challenge for the ball,” the panel wrote, calling it “a punishable offence” and ruling that the on-field decision was “a clear and obvious error” VAR should have overturned.

The ruling turns on a rule change the Premier League introduced before the season: pulling an opponent’s hair carries a yellow card and, inside the penalty area, a spot kick, with a red card reserved for pulls deemed excessively forceful or brutal. The Tarkowski-Yirenkyi incident is one of the first high-profile tests of the new guideline, and the panel’s finding is that it was simply not applied.

Lampard already made the case

Coventry manager Frank Lampard had made the same argument on the night, naming the hair-pull as one of three VAR calls he felt had gone against his side. Tarkowski had come up for a high ball into the box and, in the same challenge, first caught Coventry’s Ethan Pinnock with an elbow before taking hold of Yirenkyi’s hair.

Read also: Primoz Roglic’s next team finally revealed after Red Bull departure

“Seeing it back, he pulls on Caleb’s hair while competing with Ethan. I thought the rules were clear,” Lampard told Sky Sports. “I think it’s a foul and a penalty and they decided no.”

Lampard also questioned a second-half challenge by Vitalii Mykolenko on Taiwo Awoniyi on the edge of the box, which VAR ruled had occurred outside the area, and a possible handball by Thierno Barry as the forward scored Everton’s second goal.

Barry’s goal stays on the scoresheet

Of those other two calls, the handball on Barry’s goal was the one the panel took longest on. All five members agreed VAR had been right not to intervene, even after concluding the ball had probably brushed Barry’s hand.

“On the balance of probability the ball did accidentally strike Barry’s hand. However, the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence,” the verdict read.

Read also: Why Borussia Dortmund and Borussia Mönchengladbach share the same name

Moyes acknowledges the pattern

Everton manager David Moyes had defended his side’s result on the night, but conceded the officiating has not always worked in their favour.

“I’m bothered because we want it to be right, but we’ve had a few decisions recently where we don’t think have gone our way,” Moyes told Sky Sports.

The panel’s verdict carries no sporting consequence. The 3-1 result stands, Tarkowski faces no retrospective punishment, and Barry’s goals remain on the scoresheet.

Read also: Santos dream of Neymar, Rodrygo and Coutinho front three as Real Madrid respond

Related Stories