Premier League urged to scrap key VAR practice after controversial red card decision

Premier League urged to scrap key VAR practice after controversial red card decision

Sam Matterface and Gabby Agbonlahor used talkSPORT to pin the Premier League’s VAR problem on one specific setting, arguing that the slow-motion replay turned Jayden Bogle’s challenge on Mathys Tel…

·

Read in:

Scrap the slow motion. That was the message from the talkSPORT studio to the Premier League’s refereeing body, delivered by Matterface and Agbonlahor after they rewatched the Bogle challenge that split the league’s Key Match Incidents Panel.

“That’s another issue for me that needs to be eradicated immediately,” Matterface said of the use of slow-motion replays, according to motleedsnews.com.

Agbonlahor spelled out the logic.

“When you slow that down you’re going to say that’s a red card on every tackle,” he told listeners.

Read also: “He was annoying me so much”: Michael van Gerwen hits out after Grand Slam victory

A 3-2 split on Bogle

The two were reacting to a verdict the Premier League’s KMI Panel had just handed down. Panelists voted 3-2 to back the on-field call of no red card after reviewing the 34th-minute challenge during Leeds United’s 1-0 home win over Tottenham on Saturday 7 November. The majority considered the tackle reckless but short of the speed, force and intensity needed to be judged serious foul play.

Referee John Brooks awarded only a free-kick. VAR official Tony Harrington spent four minutes on the contact before declining to send Brooks to the pitchside monitor. Tel, who was caught on the Achilles, was substituted off injured nine minutes later, according to the Sky Sports match report.

Leeds manager Daniel Farke defended his wing-back after the final whistle.

“I know Jayden Bogle never, out of any bad intention, does the foul. He’s normally probably the softest player in the whole league,” he told Sky Sports.

Read also: Pep Guardiola’s verdict on Vincent Kompany speaks volumes after Bayern Munich success

Okafor’s late winner

The result itself was decided from the bench. Noah Okafor came on in the 77th minute and scored two minutes later, finishing a move involving fellow substitute Harry Wilson. The goal broke a five-match winless run for Farke’s side and ended a three-game winning streak for Tottenham.

A credibility week for the league

The talkSPORT segment aired in the same week the KMI Panel unanimously ruled that VAR had erred during Everton’s draw with Coventry, where James Tarkowski held Caleb Yirenkyi by the hair at a corner and no penalty was given. The panel called the non-award “a clear and obvious error” that VAR should have intervened to correct.

Matterface and Agbonlahor’s point to listeners was narrower and operational: the slow-motion review is what tips a borderline tackle over the line, and the Premier League should stop using it.

Bogle remains available for selection. A return date for Tel has not been announced by Tottenham.

Read also: “Until the end of my career”: Alexander Zverev makes troubling injury revelation

Read also: Manchester City hit by major $2bn setback following Premier League guilty verdict

Related Stories