Every Manchester United Player Ranked in 2025/26 – From Worst to Best Based on Stats

October 8, 2025 Kris Isaksen

Manchester United’s 2025/26 season has been full of ups and downs under new boss Ruben Amorim. As the Red Devils head into the October international break, we take a look at every player who has featured in the Premier League so far – ranked from worst to best

20. Joshua Zirkzee – 6.08 Rating

Zirkzee has had a forgettable start to life at Old Trafford, failing to register a single goal or assist in any competition. With no Premier League starts and minimal involvement, he’s fallen behind Benjamin Sesko in the pecking order.

19. Ayden Heaven – 6.12 Rating

With only three minutes of league football played, it’s hardly fair to judge Heaven, but he still finds himself near the bottom of the rankings. His lack of game time makes it impossible to assess his real level.

18. Altay Bayindir – 6.12 Rating

Bayindir was handed the starting goalkeeper role at the start of the season but has already lost that status. His performances haven’t inspired much confidence, and his stats reflect that.

17. Harry Maguire – 6.15 Rating

The centre-back has struggled to break into the starting XI, managing just 182 minutes in six league appearances. Maguire’s lack of rhythm and form has seen him slip down the pecking order under Amorim.

16. Kobbie Mainoo – 6.17 Rating

Despite being highly rated by fans, Mainoo hasn’t earned much trust from Amorim and has barely featured. When he has played, he’s struggled to make a real impact in midfield.

15. Manuel Ugarte – 6.27 Rating

Ugarte has underwhelmed since arriving and continues to frustrate fans, particularly as he’s often preferred over Mainoo. While his numbers are slightly better, his overall contribution has been disappointing.

14. Luke Shaw – 6.36 Rating

In a rare injury-free run, Shaw has featured in every league game this season. However, his performances have been average at best, and the stats back that up.

13. Casemiro – 6.43 Rating

The veteran midfielder continues to be trusted by Amorim but has shown inconsistency in both form and discipline. His output so far hasn’t met expectations for a player of his experience.

12. Leny Yoro – 6.47 Rating

Yoro has been a regular in the backline but hasn’t yet found consistency. While still young, his form has been hit-and-miss in a defence that’s often under pressure.

11. Diogo Dalot – 6.52 Rating

Dalot’s versatility has seen him used in various roles, including one standout Man of the Match display. But overall, his performances have lacked stability and consistency.

10. Matheus Cunha – 6.61 Rating

Cunha has shown flashes of promise despite not scoring or assisting in the league yet. Injuries have disrupted his momentum, but there's potential for more.

9. Mason Mount – 6.64 Rating

Mount is one of the few players showing improvement under Amorim, scoring recently against Sunderland. His creativity and work rate are beginning to shine through.

8. Benjamin Sesko – 6.66 Rating

Sesko has made a strong early impression with back-to-back league goals. The summer signing has taken full advantage of his chances up front.

7. Bryan Mbeumo – 6.67 Rating

Mbeumo has quietly become a reliable performer, offering energy and productivity in attack. He’s among the most consistent new additions to the squad.

6. Noussair Mazraoui – 6.77 Rating

Despite limited minutes, Mazraoui has stood out with his defensive versatility and composure. The former Bayern man has impressed when called upon.

5. Amad Diallo – 6.85 Rating

Though he’s been asked to play out of position as a wing-back, Diallo has adapted well. His recent performances show promise and attacking drive.

4. Patrick Dorgu – 6.89 Rating

Dorgu has been a constant threat from the left, even if his final product still needs refining. With one assist so far, his energy and intent haven’t gone unnoticed.

3. Bruno Fernandes – 6.94 Rating

Fernandes has featured in every league match but has operated deeper than usual. His high ranking reflects both his individual quality and the struggles of those around him.

2. Matthijs de Ligt – 6.98 Rating

De Ligt has brought much-needed stability to the defence and has performed solidly throughout the campaign. He’s come close to being the team’s top performer.

1. Senne Lammens – 7.01 Rating

The Belgian keeper has only played once but impressed with a clean sheet on debut against Sunderland. While the data is limited, fans are hopeful he could be the long-term solution in goal.