The Premier League is famous for its massive player wages. However, high salaries don’t always guarantee stellar performances on the pitch. Here’s a list of the top-paid players in the league who, according to critics, haven’t justified their hefty paychecks.
Kalvin Phillips – £150,000 per week
Photo: MaciejGillert / Shutterstock.com
Kalvin Phillips shone at Leeds, but injuries and lack of playing time have turned him into one of Manchester City’s costliest disappointments. Currently on loan, he’s yet to justify his £150,000 weekly wage.
Raheem Sterling – £162,500 per week
Photo: ph.FAB / Shutterstock.com
Raheem Sterling’s move from City to Chelsea raised eyebrows. Loaned to Arsenal, he has struggled to deliver at either club, falling short of the expectations tied to his significant pay.
After returning to the Premier League with Tottenham, Timo Werner has yet to find his stride. With just one goal in 23 matches, his £165,000 weekly salary seems hard to justify.
Once pivotal for Manchester City, Kyle Walker has seen his role diminish. As rumors swirl about a move to Italy, questions linger over whether he’s worth his current salary.
Harry Maguire – £190,000 per week
Photo: Stefan Constantin 22 / Shutterstock.com
Initially a solid performer for Manchester United, Harry Maguire’s form has dipped significantly. His £190,000 weekly wage seems excessive for a player frequently involved in costly errors.
Ben Chilwell – £200,000 per week
Photo: sbonsi / Shutterstock.com
Ben Chilwell is one of the league’s best left-backs—when fit. Persistent injuries, however, have left many questioning whether Chelsea is getting their money’s worth.
Antony – £200,000 per week
Photo: Ringo Chiu / Shutterstock.com
Antony’s flashy play hasn’t translated into meaningful contributions for Manchester United. Rumored to be heading for a loan, he remains far from justifying his high wages.
The 25-year-old German forward at Arsenal is the club’s best-paid player and the league’s 9th highest earner. With 13 goals and 3 assists in 29 games, his stats aren’t catastrophic, but critics argue he should have converted far more easy chances. His missed opportunities, like three tap-ins against Manchester United in the FA Cup, raise questions about whether he is worth his £280,000 weekly salary.
Mason Mount – £250,000 per week
ph.fab/Shutterstock.com
Since joining Manchester United, Mason Mount has been plagued by injuries and underwhelming performances. As the league’s 13th highest-paid player, he has yet to deliver consistent value.
Marcus Rashford – £300,000 per week
Photo: MDI / Shutterstock.com
Once a top scorer in the league, Rashford’s form has plummeted, leaving him out of the squad entirely. His £300,000 weekly salary is under scrutiny as fans question his long-term role.
Jack Grealish – £300,000 per week
ph.FAB / Shutterstock.com
Jack Grealish dazzled at Aston Villa but has struggled at Manchester City, failing to score a single Premier League goal in 2024. For the league’s 5th highest earner, this output is unacceptable.
Casemiro was exceptional in his first season at Manchester United but has since seen his form dip sharply. While there’s hope for a resurgence, he’s currently far from worth his league-topping salary.
Are there other players who you think are overpaid for their performances? Let us know in the comments, and we’ll keep this list updated!
