Only 5 players should be guaranteed to start for England at the 2026 World Cup
As England look toward a World Cup spread across three countries and two continents, the broader story isn’t just about qualifying cleanly — it’s about figuring out who Thomas Tuchel can truly trust. England have been good enough to reach finals, competitive enough to frighten the world’s elite, but not yet composed enough to finish the job.
And with Tuchel still putting his imprint on the squad, it’s becoming increasingly clear that only a small core of players have locked in their shirts for next summer.
Not just a perfect qualifying run — a tactical statement
GIVEMESPORT reported that England didn’t concede a single goal throughout their eight qualifiers, becoming the first European team since Yugoslavia in 1954 to achieve such a run. That record isn’t simply trivia — it points to what Tuchel wants England to become: compact, controlled and ruthless without the ball.
His immediate willingness to rotate suggests he values habits over hierarchy. But in every team, especially in tournament football, five or six players end up forming the tactical spine. And the way Tuchel’s England function, the identity of those players is starting to feel obvious.
Read also: Forest set £100m+ price for Manchester United target
Jordan Pickford – England’s emotional and tactical reference point
Goalkeeper debates are inevitable in England, but Pickford’s international résumé has reached the point where it speaks on his behalf. The numbers highlighted by GIVEMESPORT — 43 clean sheets in 81 caps — underline it, but his real value lies in how he connects England’s defensive structure.
Tuchel asks his goalkeeper to play high, act early, and keep possession secure. Pickford’s decision-making has matured to the point where England’s back line doesn’t need to second-guess him.
His nine-match clean-sheet streak, passing Gordon Banks, isn’t just historic; it’s evidence of a keeper who has grown into the psychological anchor of the side.
Unless something drastic changes, Pickford is the least debatable starter in the entire squad.
Read also: Football’s greatest never to grace a World Cup
Marc Guehi – the defender who fits Tuchel’s blueprint best
Guehi may not have the name recognition of Stones or Maguire, but his profile fits Tuchel’s system almost perfectly.
He defends proactively, holds his ground instead of plunging into tackles, and plays with a calm authority beyond his experience. GIVEMESPORT’s reporting on his rise mirrors what analysts have seen for months: he’s now England’s most reliable centre-back.
For Tuchel, who wants defenders capable of handling high possession and sudden transitions, Guehi offers the blend of athleticism and structure the system requires. His partner may change — Stones, Konsa or someone else — but his place shouldn’t.
Declan Rice – the single most irreplaceable midfielder
England’s midfield conversation is where the real uncertainty lies. The No.10 role is open. The second pivot spot is open. Even the balance between possession and pressing is still being shaped. But Rice? He’s non-negotiable.
Read also: Guardiola condemns Israel’s actions and global inaction in Gaza
Beyond the raw numbers — more than 70 caps at 26, per Transfermarkt — Rice gives England three things Tuchel cannot replace:
- Coverage in defensive transition,
- Progressive passing through mid-blocks, and
- Set-piece presence at both ends.
GIVEMESPORT was right to highlight the competition around him, but the tactical truth is simple: without Rice, England lose their structure. With him, Tuchel can experiment around the edges.
Bukayo Saka – England’s problem-solver in tight games
While the left flank still feels like a puzzle England haven’t solved, the right side is completely settled. Saka’s 14 England goals tell part of the story, but his tactical importance is even bigger.
He’s one of the few players in the squad who can create advantages on his own — with feints, body shape, or quick combinations.
Read also: 15 best penalty takers in football history
And because he drifts inside rather than relying on pure speed, he fits Tuchel’s desire for inside-forwards who help overload central spaces. As GIVEMESPORT pointed out, Saka doesn’t need to be the fastest player on the pitch to be the most dangerous.
When England are stuck, Saka is the player who unsticks them.
Harry Kane – The system in human form
It’s almost too easy to say Kane starts because he scores. The Transfermarkt record GIVEMESPORT referenced — 137 goal contributions in 113 Bayern games — is outrageous, but Kane’s real importance is structural.
He acts as England’s tempo-setter, connecting midfield to attack, dragging defenders out of shape, and dictating the height of England’s press.
Read also: Jake Paul gets unexpected boost before Joshua fight
You can replace his goals, but you cannot replace his understanding of when to drop, when to hold, and when to speed up the play. England look entirely different without him — slower, less coherent, more predictable.
Other forwards might get minutes, but none threaten his role.
England’s spine is forming — even as everything else stays fluid
Tuchel will continue to tweak and rotate; that’s part of how he works. But tournament football always comes back to a trusted few. And right now, England’s backbone — Pickford, Guehi, Rice, Saka and Kane — is the clearest part of the picture.
Everything around them might still be adjustable. Those five are not.
All statistics per Transfermarkt – correct as of 17/11/2025
Sources: GIVEMESPORT, Transfermarkt
