Every Premier League goalkeeper ranked by 2025/26 performance: from worst to best

November 12, 2025 Kris Isaksen

Goalkeepers often get overlooked in favor of flashy attackers and commanding defenders, but the 2025/26 Premier League season has shown just how vital a top shot stopper can be. Using FotMob’s goals prevented metric, which measures how many goals a keeper has saved compared to expected figures, we’ve ranked every No.1 who has played at least five matches — from the worst performer to the absolute best.

23. Caoimhin Kelleher – Brentford (-3.90)

Kelleher’s move from Liverpool to Brentford hasn’t gone to plan. The Irishman has struggled to fill the starting role, conceding nearly four more goals than expected — the worst record in the league.

22. Karl Darlow – Leeds United (-2.70)

Veteran keeper Darlow has failed to impress since Leeds' return to the top flight. At 35, his performances have been shaky, letting in 2.70 more goals than he should have.

21. Giorgi Mamardashvili – Liverpool (-2.40)

Brought in as Alisson’s backup, Mamardashvili has seen more action due to injury — and the numbers don’t flatter him. He’s underwhelmed so far, allowing 2.40 more goals than expected.

20. Sam Johnstone – Wolverhampton Wanderers (-2.10)

Wolves are rock bottom in the table, and Johnstone’s form hasn’t helped. Despite his experience, the former England international has let in 2.10 more goals than the stats suggest he should have.

19. Alphonse Areola – West Ham United (-1.70)

Areola’s pedigree, including a World Cup win with France, hasn’t translated into top form for West Ham. He’s underperforming with a -1.70 goals prevented tally, raising concerns in East London.

18. Djordje Petrovic – Bournemouth (-1.60)

Petrovic has shown promise at Bournemouth but hasn’t quite hit the expected level. Despite a bright future, he’s conceded 1.60 more goals than the average keeper would in his situation.

17. Bernd Leno – Fulham (-1.20)

A reliable presence for Fulham, Leno has dipped below his usual standard. The German international’s stats show a mild underperformance this season.

16. Robert Sanchez – Chelsea (-0.90)

Chelsea’s revolving door of signings hasn’t displaced Sanchez, but his form is average at best. The Spaniard has let in 0.90 more goals than expected in what’s been a turbulent campaign at Stamford Bridge.

15. Altay Bayindir – Manchester United (-0.80)

Bayindir started the season for United but was eventually replaced. His numbers — 0.80 goals allowed above expected — justify why Amorim turned to a new No.1.

14. Matz Sels – Nottingham Forest (-0.80)

After a strong finish last season, Sels has regressed slightly. He’s still solid, but 0.80 goals worse than expected shows a slight downturn in form.

13. Martin Dubravka – Burnley (-0.60)

The experienced Slovakian has been a steady figure for Burnley but hasn’t exceeded expectations. His -0.60 record puts him in the lower half of performers.

12. Alisson Becker – Liverpool (-0.50)

Usually among the league’s elite, Alisson’s season has been hampered by injury and inconsistency. He’s still dependable, but his -0.50 mark reflects a quieter campaign by his standards.

11. David Raya – Arsenal (-0.40)

Raya has kept an impressive number of clean sheets, but the underlying data shows he’s conceded slightly more than expected. Still, he’s been key in Arsenal’s solid defensive form.

10. Bart Verbruggen – Brighton & Hove Albion (-0.20)

One of the league’s most promising young keepers, Verbruggen has held his own at Brighton. Though slightly under average, his performances suggest a bright future.

9. Emiliano Martinez – Aston Villa (-0.10)

Martinez remains a consistent figure for Villa despite a failed move to Manchester United. He’s only marginally under his expected goals, showcasing his enduring quality.

8. Lucas Perri – Leeds United (-0.10)

In limited minutes, Perri has proven to be more effective than Darlow. He looks like the long-term No.1 for Leeds, and his performances are already trending positively.

7. Gianluigi Donnarumma – Manchester City (+0.70)

Donnarumma had big shoes to fill after Ederson, but he’s stepped in seamlessly. With 0.70 goals prevented, he’s already made his mark in City’s title challenge.

6. Senne Lammens – Manchester United (+1.50)

Signed for just £18.1 million, Lammens has been a revelation at Old Trafford. His 1.50 goals prevented prove he’s more than earned his place as United’s new No.1.

5. Nick Pope – Newcastle United (+1.50)

With Ramsdale breathing down his neck, Pope has responded in style. He’s back to his best, with strong performances backed up by 1.50 goals prevented.

4. Jordan Pickford – Everton (+1.70)

Pickford is ageing like fine wine, and Everton are reaping the benefits. The England No.1 continues to deliver big saves, preventing 1.70 goals more than expected.

3. Robin Roefs – Sunderland (+2.10)

Roefs has played a huge role in Sunderland’s Premier League survival bid. His 2.10 goals prevented highlight just how crucial he’s been since arriving in the summer.

2. Dean Henderson – Crystal Palace (+3.80)

Palace’s FA Cup-winning keeper has hit another level this season. Henderson has been nothing short of superb, saving nearly four more goals than expected.

1. Guglielmo Vicario – Tottenham Hotspur (+4.40)

No keeper in the Premier League has outperformed expectations like Vicario. With 4.40 goals prevented, the Italian has cemented his place as Spurs’ standout performer.