McIlroy debate: is he Europe's greatest golfer of all time?

McIlroy debate: is he Europe’s greatest golfer of all time?

By matching Colin Montgomerie’s all-time Race to Dubai record on Sunday in Dubai, the Northern Irishman has reignited a debate he openly admits he thinks about.

·

Read in:

Rory McIlroy dedicated his record-equalling eighth Race to Dubai title to his father Gerry, who is recovering in a Cleveland hospital after a double lung transplant in late September.

Gerry’s instruction to his son before the trip to the DP World Tour Championship was unambiguous.

“Rors, go and win me The Race to Dubai,” he told him, as McIlroy relayed to reporters at Jumeirah Golf Estates.

Second place at the season finale, won outright by England’s Tyrrell Hatton, was enough to see off Spain’s Eugenio Chacarra and seal a fifth consecutive season-long crown.

Read also: Palace have their man in Thomas Frank

Level with Monty on eight

Colin Montgomerie had stood alone on eight Order of Merit titles for more than two decades. McIlroy drew level with him on Sunday at Jumeirah Golf Estates.

McIlroy said the mark had never been on his list.

“Winning eight Order of Merits was never really in my list of goals when I was growing up,” he said after the final round.

Asked how many more he could win, his answer was blunt: “double digits”.

Read also: FIA to propose major age limits overhaul for F1

The one win that defined 2026

McIlroy’s 2026 had carried a single victory on it before Sunday. It was the Masters in April, a second green jacket in as many years and the first back-to-back Augusta triumph since Tiger Woods in 2001 and 2002.

That followed his breakthrough at the 2025 Masters, the win that completed his career Grand Slam and put him in a group with Gene Sarazen, Ben Hogan, Gary Player, Jack Nicklaus and Woods.

He now has six majors to his name.

Vardon’s seven still the European mark

On majors alone, McIlroy is not yet Europe’s king. Harry Vardon of Jersey still has more than any European, with seven won between 1896 and 1914, six Open Championships and the 1900 US Open.

Read also: Max Verstappen compared to Messi and Ronaldo as longtime Red Bull mechanic bids farewell

To take sole ownership of the European crown on that measure, McIlroy needs two more.

He is openly chasing it. He told Sky Sports after sealing the Race to Dubai:

“I feel a theme of my career over the last few years is trying to get to a point where other people may consider me as the best European that’s ever played.”

Rahm and Hatton back for 2027

McIlroy will not have the DP World Tour to himself next season. Sky Sports reports that Jon Rahm and Tyrrell Hatton are both returning as full members in 2027 while continuing their LIV Golf commitments, setting up fresh competition for a ninth Order of Merit.

Read also: Vinicius Junior opens up on Real Madrid struggles and the impossible burden he carries

Read also: Harry Kane reveals one thing he still wants to try after winning the Ballon d’Or

Related Stories