The 20 Greatest Goalkeepers in Premier League History – Ranked

July 1, 2025 Oliver Obel

The Premier League has been home to some of the finest shot-stoppers the football world has ever seen. From fearless leaders to revolutionary ball-playing keepers, these men have defined eras and transformed the role between the posts. Here’s a countdown of the 20 greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history, beginning with the resilient underdogs and building up to the undisputed kings of the craft.

20. Kasper Schmeichel

Kasper Schmeichel lived up to his legendary surname with composure and class. He was the backbone of Leicester City's fairytale 2015/16 title win, showcasing consistency across 284 appearances.

19. Mark Schwarzer

One of the Premier League’s most enduring figures, Mark Schwarzer played over 500 games and kept 152 clean sheets. His reliability was key to Fulham’s Europa League run and Middlesbrough’s top-flight stability.

18. Tim Howard

The American goalkeeper made 399 appearances and was known for his sharp reflexes and leadership. He became a fan favorite at Everton, helping them qualify for Europe.

17. Thibaut Courtois

Courtois’ time at Chelsea may have ended in controversy, but his performance on the pitch was stellar. Winning two Premier League titles in just 126 games, his commanding presence was unmatched.

16. Nigel Martyn

A model of consistency in the 1990s and early 2000s, Martyn delivered calm performances for Leeds and Everton. His 137 clean sheets from 372 games underline his dependability.

15. Pepe Reina

Pepe Reina was a cornerstone for Liverpool during his peak years, racking up 136 clean sheets. His quick reactions and intelligence made him a fan favorite at Anfield.

14. Hugo Lloris

Lloris spent over a decade as Tottenham’s No. 1 and captain, showing consistency and class. With 127 clean sheets, he was one of the best during his peak years.

13. Neville Southall

Though his Premier League years were in his twilight, Southall’s aura and impact on Everton were immense. A club legend who inspired generations with his fearless approach.

12. David James

Often underrated, David James played for five different Premier League clubs and amassed 169 clean sheets. His athleticism and shot-stopping made him a vital part of every team.

11. Joe Hart

Joe Hart won two titles with Manchester City, leading from the back during their rise to dominance. His 127 clean sheets and passionate presence defined an era for City fans.

10. Brad Friedel

Brad Friedel’s 450 appearances and 132 clean sheets reflect his remarkable longevity. He also holds the record for most consecutive appearances in Premier League history with 310.

9. Shay Given

Shay Given was a dependable force across 450 games, primarily with Newcastle United. His shot-stopping ability and consistency made him one of the league's most trusted goalkeepers.

8. Jens Lehmann

Lehmann’s legacy is anchored by his role in Arsenal’s Invincibles season, playing every match of their unbeaten 2003/04 campaign. His 54 clean sheets in 148 games underscore his impact despite a shorter stay.

7. Ederson

Ederson has revolutionized goalkeeping under Pep Guardiola at Manchester City. Known for his pinpoint passing and fearless style, he has kept 127 clean sheets in 276 games and counting.

6. David De Gea

David De Gea overcame early criticism to become one of Manchester United’s greatest-ever keepers. With 147 clean sheets and two Golden Gloves, his reflexes saved United time and again.

5. Alisson Becker

Liverpool’s defensive transformation owes much to Alisson, who joined in 2018 for a record fee at the time. He kept 21 clean sheets in his debut season and won every major trophy since.

4. David Seaman

A pillar of Arsenal’s success in the ‘90s, Seaman was known for his calm and safe hands. His 141 clean sheets in 344 matches were vital in securing two Premier League titles.

3. Edwin van der Sar

Van der Sar brought elegance and composure to Manchester United’s backline during their dominant years. His 132 clean sheets and four league titles cement his place among the very best.

2. Petr Cech

Holding the all-time Premier League record for clean sheets with 202, Cech was a wall behind Chelsea’s defense. He won four titles and set numerous records, including fewest games to reach 100 clean sheets.

1. Peter Schmeichel

The foundation of Manchester United’s dominance in the ‘90s, Schmeichel was a force of nature. His commanding presence and iconic saves led to five league titles and legendary status as the Premier League’s greatest goalkeeper.Værktøjer