The Best Premier League XI of the Last Five Years

July 22, 2025 Oliver Obel

The last five years in the Premier League have been packed with brilliance, controversy, and unforgettable performances. As the dust settles on half a decade of footballing excellence, a best XI has emerged — built not on hype, but on consistent, top-level displays. From the goalkeeper to the attacking trio, every player in this lineup has left a lasting impact on the league.

Goalkeeper: Alisson Becker

Liverpool’s transformation from top-four hopefuls to title winners began with the arrival of Alisson Becker. Though goalkeepers rarely score high in raw metrics, his composure, shot-stopping, and influence on the defensive line make him an essential presence in this elite XI.

Right-Back: Trent Alexander-Arnold

Trent Alexander-Arnold has revolutionized the role of a full-back in modern English football. His passing range, crossing accuracy, and ability to dictate play from deep positions have made him a creative force for Liverpool across multiple seasons.

Centre-Back: Virgil van Dijk

Few defenders have dominated the league quite like Virgil van Dijk. With his commanding aerial presence, positional awareness, and leadership, he’s been the bedrock of Liverpool’s success and arguably the most feared centre-back in Europe.

Centre-Back: James Tarkowski

A surprise inclusion, James Tarkowski has quietly built a case for consistency and reliability at the heart of the defence. Despite playing for teams under pressure, his defensive numbers outshine many more high-profile centre-backs in the league.

Left-Back: Andy Robertson

Andy Robertson’s tireless engine and defensive intelligence have made him a mainstay in Liverpool’s backline. He balances attacking overlaps with solid defensive duties, helping his side maintain structure and width on the left flank.

Defensive Midfield: Rodri

Rodri has operated as the heartbeat of Manchester City’s midfield, controlling tempo and shielding the defence with effortless efficiency. His presence allows others around him to shine, and his consistency in big matches has been second to none.

Central Midfield: Kevin De Bruyne

Kevin De Bruyne’s influence in the Premier League needs little introduction. Whether it was through inch-perfect assists, powerful strikes, or orchestrating attacks, his time in England left an enduring legacy before his move abroad.

Central Midfield: Bruno Fernandes

Bruno Fernandes has often been the lone creative spark in a turbulent Manchester United setup. His ability to create chances, score goals, and lead from midfield has made him one of the most impactful playmakers of the era.

Right Wing: Mohamed Salah

Mohamed Salah has been relentless, combining speed, precision, and incredible goal contributions year after year. His latest season was his most productive yet, underlining his status as one of the Premier League's most feared forwards.

Striker: Harry Kane

Harry Kane leads the line as the standout performer of the last five seasons. His blend of ruthless finishing, vision, and intelligent movement almost made him the league’s top scorer of all time before his departure.

Left Wing: Son Heung-min

Son Heung-min completes the attack, remembered for his electric pace, sharp finishing, and devastating partnership with Kane. Even as his role evolved post-Kane, his influence during their peak years remains undeniable.

Goalkeeper: Ederson (Substitute)

Ederson has been central to Manchester City’s tactical identity, playing as much with his feet as with his hands. His exceptional distribution, calmness under pressure, and ability to start attacks from deep have made him one of the most influential keepers of the modern Premier League era.

Centre-Back: William Saliba (Substitute)

Despite his relatively short time as a Premier League starter, William Saliba has emerged as a standout centre-back for Arsenal. His reading of the game, strength in duels, and maturity beyond his years have transformed the Gunners’ backline.

Right-Back: Kyle Walker (Substitute)

Kyle Walker has been one of the most consistent and physically dominant defenders in the league over the past five years. His pace, recovery ability, and experience at the highest level have made him a vital part of Manchester City’s defensive setup.

Left-Back: Luke Shaw (Substitute)

Luke Shaw has enjoyed a career resurgence, becoming one of Manchester United’s most reliable performers. Equally comfortable defending and pushing forward, he brings balance and versatility to the backline.

Midfielder: Declan Rice (Substitute)

Declan Rice evolved from a promising defensive midfielder to a complete engine room operator. His tackles, interceptions, and ability to drive forward with the ball made him one of the most reliable performers in the division.

Midfielder: Martin Ødegaard (Substitute)

Martin Ødegaard has led Arsenal with composure, intelligence, and creativity. His vision and ability to orchestrate attacks in tight spaces earned him recognition as one of the Premier League’s top playmakers.

Midfielder: Bernardo Silva (Substitute)

Bernardo Silva has been the embodiment of versatility, intelligence, and hard work in Manchester City’s midfield. Whether playing centrally, wide, or deeper, his technical ability and tireless movement have made him indispensable in Guardiola’s system.

Winger: Bukayo Saka (Substitute)

Bukayo Saka has been a consistent and fearless attacking outlet for Arsenal. Whether scoring, assisting, or breaking defensive lines, he’s shown the confidence and maturity of a veteran despite his young age.

Striker: Erling Haaland (Substitute)

In just a short time in the league, Erling Haaland shattered expectations with a record-breaking goal tally. His physical dominance and clinical finishing turned Manchester City’s attack into a goal machine.