The Definitive Ranking of All 102 Major Transfers from the 2025 Summer Window – Ranked

The 2025 summer transfer window will go down as one of the most dramatic in football history. Spending records were shattered, with Premier League clubs alone breaking the single-window record once again, and Europe’s giants engaged in tense, drawn-out sagas that kept fans on edge until deadline day.

This was also a unique window because it was split into two parts due to the FIFA Club World Cup, meaning clubs had to be more strategic than ever — either moving quickly in the early June phase or gambling late as squads took shape. We saw blockbuster moves like Liverpool smashing their transfer record for Alexander Isak, Real Madrid continuing their youth revolution with Dean Huijsen, Franco Mastantuono, and Trent Alexander-Arnold, and Barcelona betting on the high-upside potential of Roony Bardghji.

But not every deal was a masterstroke. Some moves felt rushed, overpriced, or simply unnecessary, while others were clever bargains that could transform a club’s future. This ranking focuses purely on the buying club’s grade — evaluating value for money, tactical fit, age profile, and long-term potential — to determine who came out of the 2025 summer window as winners and losers.

102. Yoane Wissa – Newcastle United (D)

Newcastle splashed £50m on a 29-year-old forward in a late scramble for depth. It’s a desperate, short-term move that looks expensive for the output they’ll likely get.

Read also: Inside Football’s Most Expensive Squads: Who Tops the List?

101. Bryan Mbeumo – Manchester United (C)

Mbeumo is a fine Premier League winger, but United paid top dollar just as his stats suggest regression. It feels like a move driven by panic rather than long-term planning.

100. Jadon Sancho – Aston Villa (C)

Villa take Sancho on loan, covering nearly all of his wages without an option to buy. It might spark him back to life, but it’s a pricey gamble for a short-term fix.

99. Ansu Fati – AS Monaco (C+)

Fati remains hugely talented, but his injury history is concerning. Monaco are betting big wages on a player who hasn’t had consistent minutes in years.

98. Jamie Gittens – Chelsea (C+)

Chelsea invested heavily in potential, but Gittens must prove he’s more than just flashes of brilliance. He has talent, but will need to improve quickly to justify the fee.

Read also: The 10 F1 Teams with the Biggest Budgets - Ranked

97. Dango Ouattara – Brentford (C+)

Ouattara is solid but not a game-changer, and Brentford paid a premium in a tough summer. This feels more like survival mode than strategic squad building.

96. Ben Doak – Bournemouth (C+)

Doak has only three Premier League appearances yet cost £25m. It’s a high-risk bet on upside as Bournemouth rebuild their squad.

95. Gio Reyna – Borussia Mönchengladbach (C+)

Reyna’s career stalled at Dortmund, and this move is a reset. Gladbach could look smart if he stays fit, but that’s been the big problem.

94. Mateus Fernandes – West Ham (C+)

West Ham overpaid £10m beyond their initial budget after a bad start to the season. Fernandes is good, but the circumstances scream panic buy.

Read also: The 25 Best Penalty Takers in Football History

93. Xavi Simons – Tottenham (C+)

Simons is a gifted dribbler but still hasn’t found consistency. Tottenham hope a change of scenery will unlock his potential.

92. Gianluigi Donnarumma – Manchester City (C+)

City get an elite shot-stopper, but his struggles with distribution are well-known. It’s a strange fit for Guardiola’s system and carries tactical risk.

91. Jack Grealish – Everton (C+)

Everton are paying big money for a player whose output has plummeted. If he rediscovers his old form, it could be brilliant — but that’s a big question.

90. Nicolas Jackson – Bayern Munich (C+)

Bayern agreed to an expensive loan plus obligation for a player they’re not fully convinced by. He’ll need to find top form to justify the cost.

Read also: Ranking the Greatest British & Irish Lions Rugby Team

89. Luis Díaz – Bayern Munich (C+)

Liverpool sold at peak value, leaving Bayern paying premium price for a 28-year-old winger. This reeks of desperation after Musiala’s injury.

88. Benjamin Sesko – Manchester United (B-)

Sesko is one of Europe’s hottest prospects but came at a huge fee. He will face immediate pressure to become United’s long-term No. 9 solution.

87. Darwin Núñez – Al Hilal (B-)

Núñez never fully fit at Liverpool, so a sale made sense, but the price is hefty. He needs to deliver consistent goals to avoid being seen as another expensive gamble.

86. Jonathan Tah – Bayern Munich (B-)

Bayern get a proven Bundesliga defender, but they’re committing major wages. He must replicate his Leverkusen form to justify this deal.

Read also: The Most Successful Clubs of the Past 25 Years - Ranked

85. Kevin – Fulham (B-)

Kevin is flashy and fun but must add end product to thrive in the Premier League. At a record fee, Fulham will expect immediate impact.

84. Álvaro Carreras - Real Madrid (B-)

Carreras is a tall, athletic full-back who drives forward aggressively. The price is steep, but Madrid are banking on his two-way potential to balance their defense.

83. Noni Madueke – Arsenal (B-)

Madueke has developed well but faces competition with Bukayo Saka. Arsenal needed a left winger, making this an odd but potentially useful signing.

82. Giovanni Leoni – Liverpool (B-)

Leoni is just 18 with limited top-flight experience, making this a long-term project. Liverpool see him as a future star, but he won’t solve problems now.

81. Eberechi Eze – Arsenal (B-)

Eze is a creative magician and should fit Arsenal well. The price is high, and he’ll be expected to deliver straight away.

80+. Omari Hutchinson – Nottingham Forest (B-)

Forest paid £37.5m for a talented winger from a relegated side. This could be a masterstroke if he develops quickly, but it’s a big outlay.

79. Carney Chukwuemeka - Borussia Dortmund (-B)

Full of talent but often injured, Chukwuemeka is a high-upside bet. Dortmund’s track record with developing young attackers makes this a calculated gamble despite the risk.

78. Christopher Nkunku – AC Milan (B-)

Nkunku never clicked at Chelsea and now gets a fresh start. If he stays fit, he can become one of Milan’s attacking leaders.

77. Nick Woltemade – Newcastle United (B-)

Woltemade is technically gifted but stylistically awkward for Newcastle. This is a future play that might take time to pay off.

76. Álex Baena – Atlético Madrid (B-)

Baena is LaLiga’s top creator but must adapt to Simeone’s combative system. This is a high-upside move if he clicks in Madrid.

75. João Pedro – Chelsea (B-)

Pedro is clever and link-up oriented, but Chelsea paid a big fee. Balancing him with Palmer and Delap will be a challenge.

74. Alexander Isak - Liverpool (B-)

Liverpool broke the British transfer record to land one of the best strikers in the world in his prime. The fee and transfer saga pile enormous pressure on him, and the B- grade reflects the high cost and the risk attached.

73. Florian Wirtz – Liverpool (B)

One of Europe’s best creators joins Liverpool for £100m. The price brings pressure, but he could elevate Klopp’s attack to new heights.

72. Tim Weah – Marseille (B)

Marseille get a versatile, hardworking player who can cover multiple roles. A smart low-risk loan that strengthens their right flank.

71. Senne Lammens - Manchester United (B)

United turned to a young Belgian keeper with great size and penalty-saving ability. He’s still inexperienced at senior level, but this is a smart long-term investment if his development stays on track.

70. Rasmus Højlund - Napoli (B)

After a difficult spell at Manchester United, Højlund gets a chance to reboot his career in Serie A. Under Antonio Conte he should thrive as a traditional No. 9, though the B grade shows he still has plenty to prove.

69. Yunus Musah – Atalanta (B)

Musah gets a new environment perfect for his energy and box-to-box style. Atalanta will hope he takes the next step in his career.

68. Loïs Openda – Juventus (B)

Juventus turn to Openda after missing other striker targets. His pace and directness make him a good fit, but he must add goals quickly.

67. Mathys Tel - Tottenham Hotspur (B)

Once one of Europe’s most hyped prospects, Tel never got regular minutes at Bayern. Spurs are betting that consistent playing time will unlock his explosiveness and finishing.

66. Victor Osimhen – Galatasaray (B)

Osimhen smashes the Turkish transfer record in a headline-grabbing move. If he dominates the Süper Lig, this could look like a bargain.

65. João Palhinha – Tottenham (B)

Palhinha adds steel to Spurs’ midfield. A smart loan deal that gives Ange Postecoglou options without tying the club down.

64. Hugo Ekitike – Liverpool (B)

Ekitike is a strong stylistic fit for Liverpool’s attack. His dribbling and movement should open space for Salah and Núñez’s replacement.

63. Martin Zubimendi – Arsenal (B)

Zubimendi is a deep-lying playmaker who makes teammates better. Arsenal finally get the metronome they have craved, though the fee reflects their desperation.

62. Mohammed Kudus – Tottenham (B)

Kudus is an electric dribbler who can change games on his own. Spurs are betting big that Thomas Frank can sharpen his decision-making and turn him into an elite creator.

61. Matheus Cunha – Manchester United (B)

Cunha is a tireless forward who can press, dribble, and score. If he maintains his Wolves form, he could become a vital part of United’s frontline.

60. Johnny Cardoso – Atlético Madrid (B)

Cardoso is a defensive-minded midfielder who wins tackles and keeps the ball moving. Simeone will love his intensity, and the fee looks like good value.

59. Alejandro Garnacho – Chelsea (B)

Garnacho is fearless and direct, bringing pace and creativity to Chelsea’s attack. The £40m fee is fair if he develops the end product his game still lacks.

58. Jarell Quansah – Bayer Leverkusen (B)

Leverkusen have replaced Jonathan Tah with a talented young English defender. If Quansah plays regularly, this could be an inspired move.

57. James McAtee – Nottingham Forest (B)

McAtee is a left-footed playmaker with vision and flair. Forest get a high-upside talent with resale value, while City smartly include a buy-back clause.

56. Tyler Dibling – Everton (B)

Dibling is an elite dribbler with raw potential. Playing alongside experienced wingers should help him develop quickly.

55. Jacob Ramsey – Newcastle United (B)

Ramsey is an athletic, attacking midfielder who suits Eddie Howe’s high-energy game. Fitness remains the only question mark over his impact.

54. Dan Ndoye - Nottingham Forrest (B)

Ndoye had a breakout season for Bologna and starred at Euro 2024. Forest get a strong, direct winger who can replace Anthony Elanga’s pace and power right away.

53. Illia Zabarnyi – PSG (B)

Zabarnyi is a calm, ball-playing defender who improves PSG’s back line. Bournemouth got a big fee, but this is a sensible buy for the French champions.

52. Giacomo Raspadori – Atlético Madrid (B)

Raspadori is a clever finisher who thrives in tight spaces. He should fit well in Simeone’s system and help replace departing forwards.

51. Viktor Gyökeres – Arsenal (B)

Gyökeres is a powerful striker who leads the line with aggression. Arsenal will hope he can replicate his Sporting CP form in the Premier League.

50. Kevin De Bruyne – Napoli (B+)

De Bruyne may be 34, but his quality is undiminished. Napoli get a world-class leader to guide their midfield in the short term.

49. Jorrel Hato – Chelsea (B+)

At just 19, Hato is already experienced and technically strong. Chelsea see him as a cornerstone for their defense for the next decade.

48. Jobe Bellingham – Borussia Dortmund (B+)

Bellingham is a physical and intelligent midfielder following in his brother Jude’s footsteps. Dortmund get another long-term project with massive upside.

47. Luis Henrique – Inter (B+)

Henrique is quick and direct, giving Inter more depth on the flanks. A fair price for a player with plenty of room to grow.

46. Dário Essugo – Chelsea (B+)

Essugo is a tireless midfielder who covers ground and wins duels. Chelsea are planning for the future with this smart pickup.

45. Eric Dier – AS Monaco (B+)

Dier brings leadership and experience to a young Monaco squad. He’ll steady the defense and mentor their prospects.

44. Patrick Agyemang – Derby County (B+)

Agyemang is a physical striker who could light up the Championship. A brave signing from Derby that shows ambition.

43. Malik Tillman – Bayer Leverkusen (B+)

Tillman is a versatile attacker who moves well off the ball. He’s a great fit to help fill the creative void left by Wirtz.

42. Thomas Müller - Vancouver Whitecaps (B+)

The German legend brings world-class football IQ and clever movement to MLS. If his teammates find him in space, he should rack up assists and goals even in the twilight of his career.

41. Anthony Elanga – Newcastle United (B+)

Elanga’s pace and work rate make him a natural fit for Howe’s system. At 23, he has room to keep improving.

40. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall – Everton (B+)

Dewsbury-Hall adds goals and creativity from midfield. Everton finally have a player to link play and support their forwards.

39. Ardon Jashari – AC Milan (B+)

Jashari impressed in the Champions League and is ready for Serie A. Milan have found a technical midfielder who can control games.

38. Evann Guessand – Aston Villa (B+)

Guessand provides depth and flexibility across the front line. With Durán and Rashford gone, he fills an important gap.

37. Lucas Chevalier – PSG (B+)

Chevalier is one of France’s top young keepers. PSG secure their future in goal, possibly preparing for Donnarumma’s exit.

36. Malick Thiaw – Newcastle United (B+)

Thiaw is a strong, quick defender who can play either side. Newcastle finally get the center-back they’ve needed.

35. Randal Kolo Muani – Tottenham (A-)

Kolo Muani gives Spurs a versatile, mobile forward on a loan. It’s a smart low-risk move for a high-quality attacker.

34. Jeremie Frimpong – Liverpool (A-)

Frimpong is an attacking full-back who brings pace and directness. Liverpool now have a very different option to Trent Alexander-Arnold.

33. Jonathan David – Juventus (A-)

David is a proven goal scorer joining on a free. Juventus get a bargain who should lead their line for years.

32. Milos Kerkez – Liverpool (A-)

Kerkez is aggressive and athletic, perfect for Klopp’s system. He could be the next Andy Robertson.

31. Paul Pogba – AS Monaco (A-)

Pogba is a low-risk, high-reward signing. If he stays fit, Monaco get a world-class midfielder essentially for free.

30. Cristhian Mosquera – Arsenal (A-)

Mosquera is a physically dominant young defender. Arteta can develop him into a future starter at a bargain price.

29. Tijjani Reijnders – Manchester City (A-)

Reijnders is a graceful passer who suits Guardiola’s style. City add yet another elegant midfielder to their squad.

28. Liam Delap – Chelsea (A-)

Delap scored 12 goals for relegated Ipswich and has big potential. At £30m, this was an easy decision for Chelsea.

27. Christian Nørgaard – Arsenal (A-)

Nørgaard is an experienced Premier League midfielder who adds stability. A smart and cost-effective signing.

26. Estêvão – Chelsea (A)

Nicknamed "Messinho," Estêvão is one of Brazil’s most exciting teenagers. Chelsea lock in a future superstar early.

25. Giorgi Mamardashvili – Liverpool (A)

Mamardashvili is one of Europe’s best young goalkeepers. Liverpool have secured their long-term No. 1 at a bargain price.

24. Piero Hincapié - Arsenal (A)

A rare left-footed center-back who is comfortable stepping into midfield and passing through lines, Hincapié fits Mikel Arteta’s system perfectly. An A grade highlights how he strengthens depth and raises Arsenal’s tactical ceiling.

23. Dean Huijsen – Real Madrid (A)

Huijsen is a technically gifted center-back compared to Piqué. Madrid acted quickly to pay his clause and secure him.

22. Kepa Arrizabalaga – Arsenal (A)

Kepa is a cheap, reliable deputy to David Raya. Perfect business for a team aiming for depth in all competitions.

21. Joan García – Barcelona (A)

García was the best shot-stopper in LaLiga last season. Barcelona have secured their future goalkeeper while weakening a rival.

20. Rodrigo De Paul – Inter Miami (A)

De Paul joins Lionel Messi in Miami in one of the most high-profile MLS transfers ever. This is a huge statement signing.

19. Jakub Kiwior – FC Porto (A)

Kiwior is a polished defender available on a favorable deal. Porto get an ideal partner for Bednarek.

18. Gabri Veiga – FC Porto (A)

Veiga returns to Europe after a spell in Saudi Arabia. Porto have pulled off a coup to elevate their midfield.

17. Rayan Aït-Nouri – Manchester City (A)

Aït-Nouri is a superb dribbler and defender. City add a top-tier left-back to an already dominant squad.

16. Rayan Cherki – Manchester City (A)

Cherki is one of Europe’s most talented young dribblers. If Pep can channel his creativity, City have a future star.

15. Manuel Akanji – Inter Milan (A)

Akanji is still in his prime and joins Inter on a favorable deal. He improves their defense immediately.

14. Harvey Elliott – Aston Villa (A)

Villa secure one of England’s brightest prospects for a bargain fee. He should thrive under Unai Emery.

13. Ederson – Fenerbahçe (A)

Ederson remains an elite goalkeeper and a leader. Fenerbahçe pull off a brilliant signing to raise their level.

12. Antony – Real Betis (A)

Antony was excellent on loan and now joins permanently. Betis get a dangerous winger at a cut price.

11. Luka Modrić – AC Milan (A)

Modrić brings leadership and Champions League-winning experience. He stabilizes a squad undergoing major change.

10. Theo Hernández – Al Hilal (A)

Hernández is one of the best left-backs in the world. Al Hilal get him for a surprisingly modest fee given his quality.

9. Leroy Sané – Galatasaray (A)

Sané is a blockbuster signing for Turkish football. He remains an elite winger and should dominate the Süper Lig.

8. Marcus Rashford – Barcelona (A)

Rashford arrives motivated after a turbulent season. Barça get a dynamic attacker at a reduced wage.

7. Franco Mastantuono – Real Madrid (A)

Mastantuono is the next big Argentinian talent. Madrid continue their youth-focused rebuild with another gem.

6. Trent Alexander-Arnold – Real Madrid (A)

Madrid paid €12m to bring Trent early — a bargain. He will revolutionize their right flank.

5. James Trafford – Manchester City (A)

Trafford is a homegrown keeper returning after a brilliant loan spell. City now have a long-term successor to Ederson.

4. Caoimhín Kelleher – Brentford (A)

Brentford pulled off a masterstroke, signing a top-class keeper for just £12.5m. He instantly upgrades their defense.

3. Sverre Nypan – Manchester City (A+)

City paid just £12.5m for one of Europe’s most gifted teenagers. This could become one of the best-value transfers of the decade.

2. Roony Bardghji – Barcelona (A+)

Barça get a potential superstar for just €2m due to his contract situation. If he returns to pre-injury form, this is a generational bargain.

1. Son Heung-Min – LAFC (A+)

LAFC smashed the MLS transfer record to land Asia’s biggest star. Son will sell shirts, pack stadiums, and could dominate the league.