The starting XI from Man Utd’s iconic 4-3 derby win in 2009

October 17, 2025 Aksel Kryhlmand

On September 20, 2009, Manchester United edged Manchester City in one of the most thrilling Premier League derbies of the modern era. The 4-3 scoreline, sealed by Michael Owen’s dramatic winner in stoppage time, lives long in the memory, but how well do you remember the actual starting XI?

Let’s revisit the 11 players Sir Alex Ferguson trusted to start that unforgettable clash at Old Trafford.

Ben Foster

With Edwin van der Sar sidelined due to injury, Foster got the nod in goal. While he had a mixed afternoon, including a costly error for City’s second goal, Ferguson kept faith in the young keeper, who was still viewed as a potential long-term successor at the time.

John O'Shea

A classic utility man, O’Shea started at right-back and put in a typically reliable performance. Never flashy but always solid, he was a trusted squad member under Ferguson, especially in high-pressure matches like this one.

Patrice Evra

Evra’s place on the left side of defence was never in doubt. He combined defensive sharpness with attacking energy, regularly supporting the attack and keeping City's right flank under control for most of the game.

Rio Ferdinand

Although his afternoon ended with a misjudged flick that led to Bellamy’s late equaliser, Ferdinand was still one of the leaders in United’s back line. At the time, he and Vidic were widely considered the best centre-back pairing in Europe.

Nemanja Vidić

Nemanja Vidic — LEVANTEMEDIA / Shutterstock.com

Vidić brought his usual physicality and commitment to the game. Up against the power of Emmanuel Adebayor, he stayed combative throughout and contributed with several key clearances and blocks in the box.

Darren Fletcher

The unsung hero of this match. Fletcher scored twice with two well-timed headers and worked tirelessly in midfield. His engine and positioning allowed others around him to take risks, and he was perhaps United’s most complete performer on the day.

Anderson

Still regarded as a promising young midfielder in 2009, Anderson was energetic in possession and added a dynamic edge through the middle. His combination of drive and technical skill was crucial in a game played at such a high tempo.

Ryan Giggs

Even in the twilight of his career, Giggs was still delivering on the biggest stage. He assisted the winning goal with a perfectly weighted pass to Owen and pulled the strings in midfield with typical vision and calm. A true match-winner, even at 35.

Park Ji-sung

Ji-Sung_Park — Magnus D, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Park’s energy and work rate were essential in disrupting City’s midfield rhythm. Though he rarely grabbed headlines, his movement off the ball and defensive cover were key to Ferguson’s tactical setup that day.

Wayne Rooney

Fresh off a strong start to the season, Rooney was at the heart of United’s attack. He opened the scoring early with a close-range finish and remained a constant threat, dragging defenders out of position and linking up play with fluidity.

Dimitar Berbatov

While he didn’t get on the scoresheet, Berbatov played a crucial role in holding up the ball and creating space for others. His touches were elegant, his control effortless, and he nearly scored twice with headers that forced top saves from Shay Given.