Top 10 Highest-Scoring Fantasy Football Seasons in NFL History

October 5, 2025 Kris Isaksen

Fantasy football has become a must-play tradition for millions of NFL fans, bringing added thrills and heartbreak to every Sunday. Over the years, a handful of players have delivered truly unforgettable campaigns — the kind that define seasons, win leagues, and live on in fantasy legend. Based on PPR scoring since 1997 (via Pro Football Reference), here are the top 10 highest-scoring fantasy football seasons ever — starting at No. 10 and working up to the all-time best.

#10 Patrick Mahomes (2022) – 417.4 Points

Patrick Mahomes had another electric season in 2022, leading the Chiefs to a Super Bowl title while taking home both regular season and Super Bowl MVP honors. He threw for a whopping 5,250 yards and 41 touchdowns, averaging 24.5 fantasy points per game in one of his most efficient campaigns yet.

#9 Marshall Faulk (2001) – 419.7 Points

The legendary Marshall Faulk was in peak form in 2001 as the heart of the “Greatest Show on Turf.” He surpassed 2,000 scrimmage yards for the fourth straight year and continued to set the standard for dual-threat backs. Even with multiple accolades under his belt, this season still stands out in fantasy lore.

#8 Lamar Jackson (2024) – 430.4 Points

Lamar Jackson didn’t win MVP in 2024, but fantasy managers couldn’t care less. The Ravens quarterback set career highs in passing yards, touchdowns, and passer rating — all while maintaining his signature rushing threat. He averaged 25.3 points per game, proving once again why he’s a fantasy superstar.

#7 Cooper Kupp (2021) – 439.5 Points

In 2021, Cooper Kupp had one of the most dominant seasons ever by a wide receiver. He led the league in receptions, receiving yards, and touchdowns, earning Offensive Player of the Year and Super Bowl MVP honors. His 439.5 fantasy points were 36 more than any other player that season.

#6 Priest Holmes (2002) – 440.7 Points

Despite playing only 14 games in 2002, Priest Holmes put together a mind-blowing fantasy season. He rushed for 1,615 yards, added 672 receiving yards, and scored 24 total touchdowns. His 31.4 fantasy points per game is one of the highest averages in history.

#5 LaDainian Tomlinson (2003) – 443.8 Points

Tomlinson was unstoppable in 2003, racking up 1,645 rushing yards at 5.3 yards per carry and scoring 17 total touchdowns. Known for his consistency and versatility, LT was the fantasy cornerstone that season — producing elite numbers week in and week out.

#4 Priest Holmes (2003) – 445.0 Points

Holmes followed up his 2002 explosion with another fantasy masterclass in 2003. He led the NFL with 27 rushing touchdowns and added nearly 700 receiving yards on 74 catches. Playing all 16 games, he narrowly edged out Tomlinson by just 1.2 points in a legendary RB showdown.

#3 Marshall Faulk (2000) – 459.9 Points

Faulk was at his absolute best in 2000, posting 2,189 total yards and 26 touchdowns in just 14 games. His 32.85 points per game that year were off the charts, and he claimed the league MVP while dominating fantasy leagues across the board.

#2 Christian McCaffrey (2019) – 471.2 Points

McCaffrey’s 2019 season is the definition of a fantasy workhorse. He became just the third player ever with 1,000+ rushing and receiving yards in a single season, tacking on 19 total touchdowns. His massive workload translated into one of the most reliable fantasy campaigns of all time.

#1 LaDainian Tomlinson (2006) – 481.1 Points

No player has ever topped what LT did in 2006. He rushed for 1,815 yards, caught 56 passes, and set an NFL record with 28 rushing touchdowns. With 481.1 points, Tomlinson delivered the gold standard of fantasy seasons — a record that still stands despite today’s expanded 17-game schedule.