As the 2024-25 Premier League season draws to a close, the focus inevitably shifts to those transfers that failed to deliver. Despite the billions spent across England’s top flight, not every signing hits the ground running. These are the ten players who failed to meet expectations, ranked from merely disappointing to outright disastrous.
10. Ian Maatsen (Aston Villa) – £37.5m
OSCAR GONZALEZ FUENTES / Shutterstock.com
Ian Maatsen arrived at Villa Park with high hopes following a strong loan at Borussia Dortmund. However, he struggled to establish himself under Unai Emery, with Lucas Digne preferred in his position for much of the campaign.
9. Matthijs de Ligt (Manchester United) – £43m
Orange Pictures / Shutterstock.com
Signed to bring leadership to United’s shaky defence, Matthijs de Ligt hasn’t committed obvious errors, but his presence hasn’t improved the team’s defensive record. With United conceding heavily, his impact has been minimal for such a hefty fee.
Jadon Sancho began brightly at Chelsea, assisting four times in his first three games. Yet his form quickly deteriorated, and the Blues are now reportedly considering cutting the loan short.
Smith Rowe started well at Fulham, but his influence faded as the season progressed. Ongoing fitness issues have once again derailed his form, leading to him being dropped from the starting lineup.
6. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall (Chelsea) – £30m
Ardfern, CC BY-SA 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Despite his connection with Enzo Maresca, Dewsbury-Hall has barely featured at Chelsea. Competition from more established midfielders has limited his opportunities, leaving his transfer looking increasingly questionable.
5. Eddie Nketiah (Crystal Palace) – £30m
Vlad1988 / Shutterstock.com
Nketiah was tipped to shine away from Arsenal, but he has struggled for consistency at Crystal Palace. With just three league goals, he’s been overshadowed by the form of Jean-Philippe Mateta.
4. Joshua Zirkzee (Manchester United) – £36.5m
Cesar Ortiz Gonzalez / Shutterstock.com
Zirkzee came in with promise after a strong season in Serie A but failed to adapt quickly. He managed only three goals before injury cut short a disappointing debut season in England.
This low-cost gamble by Liverpool has not paid off, as Chiesa has barely featured due to injuries and a lack of trust from Arne Slot. With just over 100 minutes in the league, his signing has turned into a non-factor.
2. Raheem Sterling (Arsenal) – Loan
kivnl / Shutterstock.com
Sterling’s move to Arsenal was meant to reignite his career, but it’s been the opposite. The winger has looked devoid of confidence and often found himself unused even when attacking options were limited.
1. Joao Felix (Chelsea) – £46m
Vitalii Vitleo / Shutterstock.com
Joao Felix tops the list as the most disappointing signing of the season. Brought in for a large fee, he never found his place in Maresca’s system and was quickly sent out on loan, leaving Chelsea with little to show for their investment.
