In a surprising turn for many who followed his storied managerial career, Sir Alex Ferguson has weighed in on football’s enduring ‘greatest of all time’ (GOAT) debate, placing Lionel Messi ahead of Diego Maradona. The former Manchester United boss, long known for his staunch backing of Cristiano Ronaldo, aligned himself with Graeme Souness in a discussion that highlights Messi’s remarkable longevity at the sport’s pinnacle.

The debate gained fresh relevance following Messi’s inspirational performances at the 2026 World Cup, where, at 39 years old, he led Argentina to the final before falling short of a second successive title at the New York New Jersey Stadium on July 19, 2026. This spectacular campaign preceded his announcement of international retirement, further cementing his place in football history.

Ferguson’s surprising verdict

Ferguson’s opinion emerged from a prior heated exchange between Souness and Scottish sports journalist Hugh McIlvanney, who passed away in January 2019. McIlvanney had firmly believed Maradona was superior, famously stating, “I don’t care who you played against. It’s Diego.” Souness, who had faced Maradona on multiple occasions during his playing career, held a contrasting view.

“Look, I played against Maradona five times and I’m telling you – Messi,” Souness asserted during their debate, as reported by The Times. Sir Alex Ferguson, reflecting on this discussion, ultimately sided with Souness, providing a clear rationale for his choice.

Read also: Donald Trump sparks falklands row after Argentina hit with huge FIFA fine

“I would side with Souness on that one. Maradona’s career at the very top was only a few years,” Ferguson stated, indicating that his belief in Messi having the edge over Maradona solidified around eight years ago, even before Messi secured the 2022 World Cup title.

Longevity and statistics

Ferguson’s argument hinges on the sustained excellence Messi has demonstrated over an extended period. While Maradona was Argentina’s undeniable hero at the 1986 World Cup, his peak, as Ferguson noted, was comparatively brief. Messi, by contrast, has consistently performed at an elite level for nearly two decades, culminating in a World Cup triumph and another deep run at age 39.

A look at their international careers for Argentina further illustrates this point:

• Diego Maradona: 84 appearances, 32 goals, 20 assists.

• Lionel Messi: 207 appearances, 125 goals, 68 assists.

These statistics underscore Messi’s enduring presence and prolific output on the international stage, providing a tangible basis for Ferguson’s assessment. While the GOAT debate remains subjective and includes other legends like Brazil icon Pele, who won three World Cups (1958, 1962, 1970), Ferguson’s unexpected endorsement of Messi adds a significant voice to the conversation, particularly given his past allegiances.

Read also: Sabah's Old Trafford debut: how a Lithuanian quiz-show winner reached the Champions League

Read also: Arsenal restart their Champions League chase in Naples, with Real Madrid and Bayern still to come