15 Worst Premier League Players in 2024/25 – Ranked

September 20, 2025 Oliver Obel

The 2024/25 Premier League season delivered thrilling highs and dismal lows. While some players dazzled with world-class performances, others fell short of expectations, whether through poor form, bad luck, or tactical misfit. Based on FotMob ratings, here’s a countdown of the 15 lowest-rated players in the English top flight this season.

15 – Ben Johnson (Ipswich Town – 6.37)

Ben Johnson’s Premier League return with Ipswich Town didn’t go to plan. The former West Ham full-back looked off the pace and was often a liability defensively.

14 – Axel Tuanzebe (Ipswich Town – 6.36)

Axel Tuanzebe struggled to re-establish himself at the highest level, offering little assurance at the back. His lack of consistent game time may have contributed to his underwhelming displays.

13 – Paul Onuachu (Southampton – 6.35)

Paul Onuachu couldn’t replicate his Championship form in the Premier League. Despite his physical presence, he failed to make an impact as Southampton went straight back down.

12 – Joe Willock (Newcastle United – 6.34)

Once a dynamic midfielder, Joe Willock’s influence at Newcastle has waned. He looked out of rhythm all season and failed to produce meaningful contributions.

11 – Joshua Zirkzee (Manchester United – 6.35)

Zirkzee’s debut season at Old Trafford was turbulent, marred by a humiliating early substitution and fan backlash. Although he improved slightly, his performances remained below par.

10 – Yukinari Sugawara (Southampton – 6.33)

Sugawara’s transition from Dutch football to the Premier League was rocky. He contributed as many penalties conceded as goal involvements—hardly a recipe for success.

9 – Vladimir Coufal (West Ham United – 6.32)

Coufal’s role at West Ham diminished with the arrival of Wan-Bissaka. When he did play, his impact was minimal, capping off a forgettable final season at the club.

8 – Adam Armstrong (Southampton – 6.30)

Armstrong’s struggles in front of goal led to a mid-season loan to West Brom. His meager return of two goals highlighted the gap between Championship and Premier League levels.

7 – Jack Taylor (Ipswich Town – 6.30)

Despite a high work rate, Taylor failed to make a lasting impression. He started just four league games and never really found his rhythm at the top level.

6 – George Hirst (Ipswich Town – 6.29)

Hirst had limited chances to shine but didn’t take them. Though he scored three times, his lack of influence over games was clear.

5 – Oliver Skipp (Leicester City – 6.25)

Skipp was expected to be a stabilizing figure but couldn’t lift Leicester’s midfield. He failed to register a single goal or assist in over 1,100 minutes.

4 – Rasmus Hojlund (Manchester United – 6.25)

Big things were expected after his £72 million move, but Hojlund disappointed. With just four goals and no assists, his underwhelming season has cast doubt on his future.

3 – Cameron Archer (Southampton – 6.18)

Archer’s signing was meant to spearhead Southampton’s survival bid. Instead, he managed just two goals in over 1,400 minutes and struggled to adapt.

2 – Archie Gray (Tottenham Hotspur – 6.17)

Once tipped as England’s next big star, Gray struggled after being forced to play out of position at centre-back. His potential remains, but this season was one to forget.

1 – Conor Coady (Leicester City – 6.15)

Coady’s experience was meant to steady Leicester’s defence, but it didn’t work out. Conceding regularly and showing signs of decline, he ended the season as the lowest-rated player in the league.