Manchester City case takes new twist as Premier League faces potential legal battle

Manchester City case takes new twist as Premier League faces potential legal battle

With Etihad Airways and Etisalat weighing defamation claims over the 115-charges ruling, chief executive Richard Masters is asking member clubs to pay the personal legal bills of the Premier League’s…

·

Read in:

Richard Masters and the four other members of the Premier League board have put a two-page proposal to clubs this week asking them to cover the directors’ personal legal costs if Manchester City’s sponsors sue over the September ruling. The item is on the agenda for a league meeting on Thursday and would need the backing of at least 14 of the 20 clubs.

The agenda paper does not name Manchester City, Etihad Airways or Etisalat. It would still rewrite Article 35, which at present only reimburses directors whose cases succeed, so that clubs foot the bill regardless of the outcome. Alongside Masters, chairwoman Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC would all fall inside the expanded protection.

Etihad Airways issued its own statement within 24 hours of the September ruling, “categorically rejecting any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements”. The airline added that the Premier League had never contacted it during the proceedings against the club.

Etisalat weighs a defamation claim

The Emirati telecoms group, valued at more than £40bn, issued a statement on Monday calling the ruling, as it relates to Etisalat, “entirely false and defamatory”, and said it was considering its legal options. It has not yet filed suit.

Read also: Wout van Aert and Mathieu van der Poel caught up in disturbing privacy scandal

Industry estimates put the potential exposure in the billions of pounds if corporate defamation claims proceed and the appeal does not overturn the commission’s findings.

£900m and the Abu Dhabi defence

An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of 114 of the 115 charges on 28 September 2026, concluding that the club had used sham sponsorship deals to inflate revenues or reduce costs by around £900m across nine seasons from 2009 to 2018. The club lodged its appeal on 1 October.

Ferran Soriano, Manchester City’s chief executive, told SportBible the entire case rested on “a single false accusation; that the owner’s personal money was somehow and secretly put into the club via some sponsors from Abu Dhabi”. The appeal is expected to run for several days in mid-December 2026, with a verdict in early 2027.

If the appeal upholds the commission, a separate sanctions hearing follows. Punishments could stretch from fines to points deductions, a transfer embargo or, in the outside case, expulsion. If the appeal clears the club, the commercial threat already in the air does not disappear either, which is why the directors want the Article 35 change regardless of how the case ends.

Read also: Pochettino eyes £40m replacement as Manchester United consider selling Matthijs de Ligt

Sports integrity chief warns of a drawn-out process

Emanuel Macedo de Medeiros, global chief executive of the Sport Integrity Global Alliance, told reporters that “justice needs to be served swiftly. That is very important.” The lawyer, who argued that the final decision must leave no room for doubt, warned that the longer it takes, the more controversy it will generate.

The sponsors have made the next step clear enough; Etihad is exploring legal action, Etisalat is weighing it, and both are holding fire until the appeal board rules. The Premier League’s response, before any of that happens, is to spread the legal risk across its own membership.

Clubs vote on Thursday.

Read also: Boca Juniors could achieve extraordinary five-trophy feat in 2026

Related Stories