The 14 Best Scrum-Halves in the World – Ranked from Lowest to Highest

April 4, 2025 Rasmus Kristensen

One of the most talked-about positions in modern rugby, the scrum-half plays a crucial role in controlling the tempo and linking forwards and backs. With the game evolving rapidly and demands on players higher than ever, standing out at number nine is no easy feat.

We’ve taken a closer look at the world’s top performers in this key role—based on current form, 2024 achievements, and overall impact—and ranked the 15 best scrum-halves in the world right now.

14. Tom Carr-Smith (England)

Still only 22, Tom Carr-Smith has emerged as one of the brightest young talents in English rugby. With standout performances for Bath, he’s shown exceptional speed, awareness, and maturity well beyond his years.

Read the full article

13. Sanele Nohamba (South Africa)

A versatile playmaker who can slot in at both scrum-half and fly-half, Nohamba has grown into a key figure for the Lions in South African rugby. His sharp kicking game and eye for gaps have earned him increasing attention at the international level.

12. Ali Price (Scotland)

A mainstay for Scotland over the past few seasons, Price combines quick distribution with solid decision-making. Though challenged by younger talents, his experience and composure keep him firmly in the mix.

11. Nic White (Australia)

Now a veteran, White remains an influential figure for the Wallabies. Known for his grit, sniping runs, and vocal leadership, he continues to play a vital role both on and off the field.

10. Herschel Jantjies (South Africa)

Jantjies made an instant impact when he first broke into the Springbok setup and remains a dynamic threat. With quick feet and a sharp rugby brain, he offers real danger in broken play situations.

9. Aaron Smith (New Zealand)

Though past his prime, Smith is still one of the most technically sound scrum-halves in world rugby. His passing, vision, and game control are elite, and he continues to mentor the next generation of All Black nines.

8. Faf de Klerk (South Africa)

With his trademark aggression and energy, de Klerk remains a game-changer. Whether it’s a box kick under pressure or a bone-crunching tackle, he brings intensity and unpredictability to every match.

7. Ben Youngs (England)

England’s most-capped player continues to be a reliable presence. While no longer the first choice, Youngs brings immense experience, calmness under pressure, and a deep understanding of the international game.

6. George Horne (Scotland)

Explosive off the mark and a proven try-scorer, Horne offers a more attacking edge from the nine jersey. His form for Glasgow and Scotland has seen him rise in status in recent years.

5. Alex Mitchell (England)

After helping England to a World Cup semi-final and guiding Northampton to a Premiership title, Mitchell has become the best scrum-half in the English game. He’s quick, composed, and thrives in chaotic situations.

4. Cam Roigard (New Zealand)

Filling Aaron Smith’s shoes was never going to be easy, but Roigard is doing just that. His speed and nose for the tryline have made him a lethal option in the All Blacks’ new era.

3. Grant Williams (South Africa)

Williams’ blistering pace and versatility—he can also cover wing—make him a valuable asset. He’s made a strong claim to be South Africa’s number one scrum-half going forward.

2. Jamison Gibson-Park (Ireland)

A crucial part of Ireland’s recent success, Gibson-Park brings tempo, creativity, and consistency to the role. Even as Ireland and Leinster have hit some setbacks, his personal form remains rock solid.

1. Antoine Dupont (France)

There’s only one rightful number one. Dupont continues to redefine the scrum-half position with his power, pace, vision, and complete skillset. A Champions Cup winner, Top 14 champion, and World SVNS Player of the Year in 2024—he’s simply on another level.