England’s record Test wicket-taker walked into a meeting at Old Trafford earlier this month expecting to talk about where his captaincy had taken Lancashire in a difficult season. He walked out knowing the club was moving on without him.

Lancashire’s new director of cricket Paul Farbrace and chief executive Richard Kenyon broke the news around 20 October. The club made the decision public two days later.

“A couple of minutes in I realised it wasn’t a conversation. I was being told they thought the best way for the team to move forward was without me. I was quite shocked,” Anderson told the Tailenders podcast.

The season that was not enough

Anderson had just captained Lancashire through a County Championship season in which he personally took 50 wickets at an average of 17. The team finished second from bottom of Division Two.

Read also: Bearman makes his pitch: ‘Continuing with Haas is my target’

He said on the podcast that he had wanted to see his career out with the club he supported as a boy, and the gap between his own figures and the verdict unsettled him. He told the Tailenders he had spent the whole season asking himself and the head coach whether they were doing more harm than good, and that the meeting pushed that doubt further.

“Is there something fundamentally wrong with me as a person?” he said.

Not every voice was surprised

Former England batter Mark Butcher said the call made sense to him once he looked past the names involved. Butcher said on the Wisden Cricket Weekly podcast that he completely understood a club that had finished second from bottom choosing to reset, and suggested Lancashire supporters might see Farbrace’s point in five or six years’ time.

Farbrace is newly in post, and the attack he inherits has to work when Anderson is not there, whether that moment arrives this winter or in a couple of seasons.

Read also: Lionel Messi singles out World Cup opponent in vote no other Ballon d’Or juror made

What happens now

Anderson, who turns 45 in July 2027, has not decided whether to carry on. Several counties are understood to have made contact since the announcement, though he told the podcast he could not see Yorkshire being one of them.

Ten days on from the meeting, he said he is sad about the way it has ended at Lancashire but has started to get excited about what comes next, whether that is more cricket or something else entirely.

Read also: Headbutt, no red card: why Madueke escaped punishment in Liverpool vs Arsenal