Roy Keane & Patrick Vieira’s Dream Combined XI: Arsenal and Manchester United Icons United

July 29, 2025 Oliver Obel

Two fierce rivals turned punditry partners, Roy Keane and Patrick Vieira, joined forces to create their dream combined XI made up of Arsenal and Manchester United legends. Their selections, filled with iconic names and bold omissions, sparked intense debate across the football world. From the backline to the forward duo, the team reflects the grit, flair and dominance of both clubs during the golden era of the Premier League.

Goalkeeper: Peter Schmeichel

Photo: Maciej Rogowski Photo / Shutterstock.com

Roy Keane insisted that Peter Schmeichel was the obvious pick in goal, even if Vieira preferred David Seaman. Despite Seaman’s superior clean sheet percentage, Schmeichel’s aura, shot-stopping brilliance and game-changing saves made him an irreplaceable choice for Keane—and ultimately, for the team.

Right-Back: Lauren

Vieira got his way here, opting for Arsenal’s Invincibles-era full-back Lauren over the more decorated Gary Neville. Known for his defensive solidity and ability to support attacks, Lauren was an underrated but vital piece of Arsenal’s dominance in the early 2000s.

Centre-Back: Tony Adams

There was no argument when it came to Arsenal legend Tony Adams. His leadership, fearlessness, and old-school defending made him a cornerstone of the backline. Keane admired his mentality and accepted Adams without hesitation.

Centre-Back: Jaap Stam

Keane emphatically named Jaap Stam, stating you simply “can’t have a team without him.” Vieira agreed, calling the Dutchman “unbelievable.” Stam's intimidating presence and dominance at the back made him one of the most feared defenders of his era.

Left-Back: Denis Irwin / Ashley Cole

ph.FAB / Shutterstock.com, D. Ribeiro / Shutterstock.com

This was the only position the pair couldn’t agree on, with Keane backing his fellow Irishman Denis Irwin for his consistency and professionalism. Vieira, however, was adamant that Ashley Cole was the superior full-back, citing his defensive quality and success with both Arsenal and Chelsea.

Right Midfield: Robert Pires

Vieira stunned many by selecting Robert Pires over David Beckham on the right flank. Keane was less than pleased, but Vieira valued flair and unpredictability more than Beckham’s free-kicks and work rate, giving Pires the edge for creativity.

Centre Midfield: Patrick Vieira

Keane returned the favour by naming Vieira in midfield, despite their long-standing rivalry. He praised Vieira’s commanding presence, ball-winning ability, and knack for scoring important goals, especially against United.

Centre Midfield: Roy Keane

Vieira likewise included Keane without hesitation, showing deep respect for his old adversary. He admired Keane’s relentless drive, intensity, and leadership, which made him the heartbeat of Manchester United’s engine room.

Left Midfield: Cristiano Ronaldo

Manchester United, Cristiano Ronaldo — photoplanet.am / Shutterstock.com

Vieira insisted Ronaldo had to be in the team, even if his best years came after Keane’s departure. Despite his youth at the time, Ronaldo’s explosive talent, flair, and future greatness were already clear to see.

Striker: Thierry Henry

Vieira called Henry the greatest Premier League striker of the last 20 years, and Keane didn’t argue. With four Golden Boots and a blend of speed, skill and clinical finishing, Henry’s inclusion was inevitable.

Striker: Eric Cantona

Keane struggled with this pick, torn between Eric Cantona and Ruud van Nistelrooy, but ultimately chose Cantona. He cited Cantona’s aura, creativity and game-changing presence as the spark behind United’s early 90s dominance.