The remainder of the 2025-26 season will define Mikel Arteta’s legacy at Arsenal, according to Jamie Carragher, who suggested the Spaniard’s reputation could swing between “genius” and “fraud” in the coming weeks. Carragher’s strong comments came ahead of Arsenal’s Champions League semi-final first leg against Atletico Madrid, which ended in a 1-1 draw.

Arteta, who took the helm at Arsenal in 2019 and secured the FA Cup in 2020, finds his team at a critical juncture. While they lead the Premier League title race, holding a narrow three-point advantage over Manchester City, their season has seen exits from both the EFL Cup, losing the final to Manchester City, and the FA Cup, where they were knocked out by Southampton.

Arteta’s defining moment

Carragher, speaking alongside Thierry Henry, articulated the high stakes for the Arsenal manager. “We’re a month away from deciding what Mikel Arteta is,” Carragher stated, as reported by GiveMeSport. “In a lot of people’s eyes, he’ll either be a genius or he’ll be a fraud. That’s the nature of it. I don’t agree with either of those statements.”

The Gunners are currently in the Champions League semi-finals for the second consecutive season, eyeing their first final appearance since 2006. This deep run in Europe’s elite competition, coupled with their Premier League challenge, presents a monumental opportunity for Arteta to secure major silverware and cement his standing.

Read also: Cristiano Ronaldo's former chef reveals banned drink and diet secrets

Henry defends pragmatic approach

Sitting to Carragher’s right, Arsenal legend Thierry Henry offered a pragmatic defence of his former club’s playing style, which has drawn recent criticism for a perceived lack of creativity and reliance on set-pieces. Henry’s comments, made on CBS Sports, came as Arsenal has struggled to score more than one goal in each of their last seven matches.

“They play a certain way, Mikel Arteta plays a certain way, we’re strong on set-pieces, solid, we don’t create a lot,” Henry acknowledged, as reported by Metro. He urged fans to accept the team’s current approach, especially with so much on the line.

“I would just like to see a win, that will do for me and bring something to The Emirates. You have to be pragmatic sometimes. You cannot always be Bayern Munich or Paris Saint-Germain, we play a different way. I think people have to accept the fact that Mikel Arteta goes about the game like that and hopefully we can win.”

As Arsenal navigates the final stretch of the Premier League season and prepares for the crucial Champions League semi-final second leg, the pressure on Arteta is immense. The coming month will undoubtedly shape the narrative around his tenure and potentially deliver the major trophy Arsenal fans have craved.

Read also: Arsenal weighing shock transfer to re-sign ‘manipulated’ talent they sold for peanuts

Sources: www.givemesport.com, metro.co.uk

Read also: Hakimi ruled out of Champions League semi-final second leg