Usain Bolt, the legendary Jamaican sprinter and arguably the most recognizable face in track and field history, has boldly asserted his claim as the greatest Olympian of all time, placing himself above American swimming icon Michael Phelps. The declaration, made following the Rio 2016 Olympics, reignites a long-standing debate among sports enthusiasts about how to compare unparalleled success across different disciplines.

Bolt’s sprint supremacy and golden tally

Bolt’s Olympic career spanned three Games, where he consistently dominated the sprint events. He secured a remarkable eight gold medals, etching his name into the record books as the only man to win the 100m and 200m titles at three consecutive Olympics:

• Beijing 2008: Gold in 100m and 200m.

• London 2012: Gold in 100m, 200m, and the 4x100m relay with the Jamaican team.

• Rio 2016: Gold in 100m, 200m, and the 4x100m relay.

Beyond his Olympic triumphs, Bolt remains the world record holder in both the 100m and 200m sprints, setting times of 9.58 seconds and 19.19 seconds respectively at the 2009 World Athletics Championships in Berlin. These records underscore his claim to being the “fastest man on the planet.”

Speaking on the Dan Patrick Show after his final Olympic appearance in Rio, Bolt articulated his self-belief and the drive behind his achievements. “I would have to go for myself, for sure. It’s just hard work and dedication. It’s what I wanted (to be the fastest man on the planet) so I knew if I wanted it, I had to work for it. I have a great team around me, a great coach that helps me to stay focused, and I just work towards what I want. I’m just always staying on top. When I started I was quick, but I think when I was like 15 or 16 was when I really realised I had a great talent,” Bolt stated, as reported by GiveMeSport. He retired from athletics in 2017 after the World Championships in London.

Read also: Verstappen names the greatest prize in his life

Phelps’s unprecedented medal haul

While Bolt’s impact on his sport is undeniable, Michael Phelps’s Olympic medal count presents a formidable counter-argument in the GOAT discussion. Phelps competed in five different Olympic Games, making his debut at just 15 years old in Sydney 2000, and continued through Athens 2004, Beijing 2008, London 2012, and Rio 2016.

The American swimmer amassed an astonishing 28 Olympic medals in total, including an unparalleled 23 gold medals. In his final appearance at Rio 2016, Phelps added five gold medals and one silver to his collection. According to Wikipedia’s list of multiple Olympic gold medalists, Phelps tops the all-time rankings, a position that dwarfs Bolt’s 17th place on the same list.

The debate between Bolt and Phelps highlights the challenge of comparing athletes from vastly different sports. While Bolt dominated in events measured in mere seconds, Phelps’s swimming career allowed for participation in numerous events per Games, leading to a significantly higher medal count. Both athletes, however, undeniably transcended their respective sports to become global icons.

Read also: More bad news for Infantino as another major nation turns against him

Read also: Manchester United target Premier League star